"Fever"
1958 nominee for Record of the Year
Winner: Domenico Modugno, "Volare"

"Fever"
1958 nominee for Best Vocal Performance, Female
Winner: Ella Fitzgerald, The Irving Berlin Songbook

"Alright, Okay, You Win"
1959 nominee, Best Vocal Performance, Female
Winner: Ella Fitzgerald, "But Not for Me"

Latin a la Lee
1960 nominee, Best Vocal Performance, Album, Female
Winner: Ella Fitzgerald, Mack the Knife: Ella in Berlin

"I'm Gonna Go Fishin'"
1960 nominee, Best Vocal Performance, Single, Female
Winner: Ella Fitzgerald, "Mack the Knife"

"Heart"
1960 nominee, Best Performance by a Pop Single Artist
Winner: Ray Charles, "Georgia On My Mind"

Live at Basin Street East
1961 nominee for Best Solo Vocal Performance, Female
Winner: Judy Garland, Judy at Carnegie Hall

"I'm a Woman"
1962 nominee for Best Solo Vocal Performance, Female
Winner: Ella Fitzgerald, Ella Swings Brightly with Nelson Riddle

"Is That All There Is?"
1969 nominee for Record of the Year
Winner: The Fifth Dimension, "Aquarius/Let the Sunshine In"

"Is That All There Is?"
1969 nominee for Best Contemporary Vocal Performance, Female
Winner: Peggy Lee, "Is That All There Is?"

Miss Peggy Lee Sings the Blues
1988 nominee for Best Jazz Vocal Performance, Female
Winner: Betty Carter, Look What I've Got

The Peggy Lee Songbook: There'll Be Another Spring
1989 nominee for Best Jazz Vocal Performance, Female
Winner: Ella Fitzgerald, All That Jazz

Lifetime Achievement Award
1995